...But you don't know which one it's behind. Okay, no, okay, if you were right, and it's behind 1, then he has to open 2 or 3. Say he opens 3. 3's empty. But now you have 1 and 2, and you don't know if it's behind 1 or 2. But if it's behind 2, and he opens 3, you...still don't know if it's behind 1 or 2, you just know it's not behind 3. Cuz if it's--
No, look, hold on, you're literally proving my point though, there's no always winning, it's still 50-50! You don't know if you were right if you chose 1 and it's behind 1. He has to open 2 or 3. If it's behind 2, then he has to open 3, and if it's behind 3, he has to open 2. You at no point know if it's behind 1, because he already has to open 2 or 3!
no subject
No, look, hold on, you're literally proving my point though, there's no always winning, it's still 50-50! You don't know if you were right if you chose 1 and it's behind 1. He has to open 2 or 3. If it's behind 2, then he has to open 3, and if it's behind 3, he has to open 2. You at no point know if it's behind 1, because he already has to open 2 or 3!